Pernicious Practices (stuff we see that will get folks in trouble!) Today’s Rant – Bill & Hold

The current intense TTB and ABC enforcement climate is grabbing the attention of the wine, spirits and beer industries. We are seeing regulatory attacks on allegedly unlawful promotions to the trade and to consumers, illegal consignment sales and other allegedly unlawful distribution and business practices involving retailers and suppliers engaging in what would be normal commercial practices for any industry other than alcohol. Discipline for bad acts ranges from million-dollar-plus fines to actual license suspensions. Not good for the balance sheet or employee morale.

The regulators for their part are not helping because (at least with the California ABC) there is no ability to obtain reliable pre-enforcement rulings on any specific practice or program. The best that can be done is an email from the Trade Enforcement Unit to the effect they don’t offer advisory opinions and the industry member inquiring is running the program at their own risk.

Further, the ABC Act is so riddled with poorly drafted exceptions that even the ABC doesn’t always understand what is, and what isn’t, allowed. This makes the ABC’s reticence to advise understandable.

Some states (such as New York) provide a protocol for obtaining a declaratory ruling on the legality of proposed programs. The NYSLA rulings are published and provide industry guidance. We would love to see a declaratory approval (or disapproval) procedure available in California and encourage our friends and colleagues to lobby their elected officials to pass a statute requiring the ABC to provide guidance binding on the agency.

Meanwhile, we will engage in occasional rants about business practices we see that, if they are brought to the attention of the agencies, will result in administrative sanctions. The reason for the “pernicious practices” rants is those engaging in the practice are generally blithely unaware of the danger that the practice creates for them. No one likes to be told that a practice “everyone is doing” is unlawful.

Today’s rant is about “Bill & Hold.”

Bill & Hold is a child of the cumulative quantity discount program approval that the ABC blessed back in 1997 (we saved the letter) when the Trade Enforcement Unit was identified by the more industry friendly title – Business Practices Unit. We miss the BPU because it would approve or disapprove programs submitted to it for consideration.

The ABC Act prohibits a supplier from providing “anything of value” to a retailer unless specifically permitted by the Act. Things of value include “free storage” of already purchased inventory. There is no specific statutory period within which goods purchased must be picked up (or delivered) but advance purchasing practices that incorporate multiple unit discounts (such as CQD programs that run over several months) for goods not delivered within the month of ordering result in providing the retail purchaser with both a lower price and free storage (free storage frees up the retailers warehouse space, a clear benefit to the retailer at the expense of the supplier). This is called “Bill & Hold.” We have advised our clients it is not a permitted practice and they undertake it at their peril.

This is conceptually different from “futures” purchases where the buyer is making an advance payment (or deposit) to reserve the right to finalize the purchase of goods not yet imported or have not yet been produced.

Bill & Hold is exactly the sort of practice that could (and should) be addressed (up or down) by a declaratory ruling statute. Some are now engaging in this practice, but effective compliance counseling requires an ABC that understands how business works, and that will adopt consistent policies that can be relied upon.

If our readers have other “pernicious practices” of concern, please let us know and we will do the analysis and publish the results.

  1. The TTB Crusade Against Small Producers and the “Consignment Sale” Business Model
  2. TTB Protocols, Procedures, and Investigations
  3. Wine in a 250 ML can – the Mystery of the TTB packaging Regulations and Solving the Problem by Amending the Regulations
  4. The Passing of John Manfreda of the TTB: a Tragedy for his family and a Tragedy for the Industry he so Faithfully Served for so Long.
  5. Pride in a Job Well-done, or Blood Money? The Cost of Learning the Truth from the TTB about the Benefits to Investigators from Making Cases Against Industry Members
  6. How ADA Website Compliance Works – The Steps You Can Take to Protect Yourself, Your Website and Your Social Media from Liability
  7. Supplier and Distributor Promotional “Banks,” Third Party Promotion Companies and Inconsistent TTB Enforcement, Oh My!
  8. “A Wrong Without a Remedy – Not in My America” – The TTB Death Penalty for Not Reporting Deaths
  9. Is a 1935 Alcohol Beverage Federal Trade Practice Law Stifling Innovation?
  10. Decoding the BCC’s Guidance on Commercial Cannabis Activity.
  11. Prop 65 - Escaping a "Notice of Violation"
  12. TTB Consignment Sales Investigations - What is Behind the Curtain of the TTB Press Releases?
  13. Heads Up! The ABC Is Stepping Up Enforcement Against Licensees Located Near Universities
  14. Coming Soon: New Mandatory Training Requirements for over One Million “Alcohol Servers” In California – September 1, 2021 will be here quickly
  15. 2019 Legislative Changes for California Alcohol Producers – a Blessing or a Curse?
  16. A Picture (On Instagram) Is Worth A Thousand Words
  17. Playing by the Rules: California Cannabis Final Regulations Takeaways
  18. Hinman & Carmichael LLP Names Erin Kelleher Partner and Welcomes Gillian Garrett and Tsion “Sunshine” Lencho to the Firm
  19. Congress Makes History and Changes the CBD Game for Good
  20. Pernicious Practices (stuff we see that will get folks in trouble!) Today’s Rant – Bill & Hold
  21. CBD: An Exciting New Fall Schedule… or Not?
  22. MISSISSIPPI RISING - A VICTORY FOR LEGAL RETAILER TO CONSUMER SALES, AND PASSAGE OF TITLE UNDER THE UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE
  23. California ABC's Cannabis Advisory - Not Just for Stoners
  24. NEW CALIFORNIA WARNINGS FOR ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES AND CANNABIS PRODUCTS TAKE EFFECT AUGUST 30, 2018, NOW INCLUDING ADDENDUM REGARDING 2014 CONSENT AGREEMENT PARTIES AND PARTICIPANTS
  25. National Conference of State Liquor Administrators – The Alcohol Industry gathers in Hawaii to figure out how to enforce the US “Highly Archaic Regulatory Scheme.”
  26. Founder John Hinman Honored with the Raphael House Community Impact Award
  27. ROUTE TO MARKET AND MARKETING RESTRICTIONS - NAVIGATING REGULATORY SYSTEM CONSTRAINTS
  28. Alcohol and Cannabis Ventures: Top 5 Legal Considerations
  29. ATF and TTB: Is Another Divorce on the Horizon? What’s Going on with the Agency?
  30. STRIKE 3 - YOU REALLY ARE OUT! THE ABC'S STRICT APPLICATION OF PENALTIES FOR SALES TO MINORS
  31. TTB Temporarily Fixes Problem with Fulfillment Warehouse Tax Credits - an “Alternate Procedure” for Paying Taxes & Reporting
  32. CUSTOMERS WHO HAVE HAD ONE TOO MANY - THE FREE TRANSPORTATION DILEMMA
  33. The Renaissance of Federal Unfair Trade Practices - Current Issues and Strategies
  34. ‘Twas the week before New Year’s and the ABC is out in Force – Alerts for the Last Week of 2017, including the Limits on Free Rides
  35. Big Bottles, Caviar and a CA Wine Strong Silent Auction for the Holidays!
  36. The FDA and the Wine and Spirits Industry – Surprise inspections anyone?
  37. NORTHERN CALIFORNIA WILDFIRES: UPDATED REGULATORY AGENCY DISASTER RELIEF RESOURCES AT A GLANCE
  38. NORTHERN CALIFORNIA WILDFIRES: REGULATORY AGENCY DISASTER RELIEF RESOURCES AT A GLANCE
  39. Soon to come to your Local Supermarket– Instant Redeemable Coupons of the digital age!
  40. The License Piggyback Dilemma – If it Sounds Too Good to be True, it Probably is
  41. A timely message from our Florida colleagues on the tied house laws, the three-tier system and the need for reform
  42. ABC Declaratory Rulings – A Modest Proposal Whose Time has Come
  43. More on FDA Inspections - Breweries, Distilleries and Questions
  44. WHY THE FDA IS INSPECTING WINERIES
  45. Senate Bill 378—The Proposed Demise of Due Process for Alcohol Licensees
  46. ABC Enforcement - Trends and Predictions
  47. The Corruption Chronicles – Volume One: A New Hope
  48. New Alcohol Delivery Oversight on the Horizon
  49. Michigan: Canary in the DtC Coal Mine?
  50. California ABC and Federal Credit Laws – Active Enforcement and Lots of Questions!
  51. Big Bottles For The Holidays - The Highest Calling Of The Winemaker's Art
  52. FINAL COMMENTS TO TTB NOTICE 160 DUE ON WEDNESDAY DECEMBER 7TH – WE ARE ASKING THE TTB TO EXTEND THE COMMENT PERIOD AGAIN TO ALLOW FOR INDUSTRY NEGOTIATION AND ALIGNMENT OF INTERESTS
  53. SONOMA COUNTY WINERY USE PERMITS, EVENT RESTICTIONS AND DTC
  54. New TTB Labeling Requirement Regulations: Out-of-State Bottling Is Not Created Equal and Consumers Right to Know Where the Grapes in their Wine Come from is Compromised
  55. Isn't A Written Agreement With A Distributor Worthless In A Franchise State?
  56. Crowd Funding for Alcohol Producers and Retailers – Down the Rabbit Hole with the Tied House laws
  57. Everything you ever wanted to know about the BPA Warning Statement but were afraid to ask
  58. AB 2082 - A Hunting License for Police and a Lethal Weapon for Politicians that Deprives Licensees of Currently Available Due Process Rights
  59. “Better Late Than Never”-- Judge in Illinois Dismisses 201 Sales Tax Cases against Retailers
  60. The Day the Music Almost Died: The Story of the BottleRock ABC Accusations, the ABC Appeals Board and a Victory for a Common Sense Interpretation of the Tied House Laws
  61. The Arsenic in Wine Class Action Dismissal – what it means
  62. Counterfeit or Artisanal Mexican Spirits? Pick your Poison, or your lime wedge
  63. Warning - CA ABC enforcement teams are on the prowl this weekend!
  64. RELIEF AT LAST! ILLINOIS MOVES TO FIX THE SALES TAX LAWSUITS AGAINST OUT-OF-STATE SELLERS BUT PROPOSES TO PENALIZE WINERIES AND RETAILERS THAT SHIP WITHOUT PERMITS
  65. The TTB Speaks on Category Management or, be Careful What you Ask for Because you might Get it!
  66. Hinman & Carmichael LLP Announces the Addition of Jeremy Siegel to its team of top beverage law lawyers
  67. 2016 LEGISLATIVE UPDATES: Part IV
  68. 2016 LEGISLATIVE UPDATES: Part III
  69. 2016 LEGISLATIVE UPDATES: Part II
  70. 2016 LEGISLATIVE UPDATES: Part I
  71. Hinman & Carmichael LLP is Hiring!
  72. John Hinman Presents NBI Webinar on Basics of Alcohol Beverage Law
  73. ABC DISMISSES SAVE MART GRAPE ESCAPE ACCUSATION BUT REFUSES TO ADOPT JUDGE’S DECISION FINDING NO STRICT LIABILITY FOR ABC VIOLATIONS
  74. Speakeasies are still with us, and proliferating!
  75. The War for the Soul of Sonoma County – the Winery Working Group Battle
  76. Santa Claus isn’t the only one coming to town this Christmas!
  77. Arizona's Direct to Consumer Shipping Rules - An Exercise in Complexity
  78. AB 780 - Social Media and the ABC: The California Legislative “Fix” that Fails
  79. Illinois Finally Offers Certainty and Relief for Victims of Sales Tax Lawsuits, but Prompt Action is Required in Pending Cases
  80. A Modest Proposal – Adopt the federal rule on Tied-House liability in California
  81. The Grapes Escaped - Why the First Amendment Matters
  82. Appellate Court Ruling Strikes Blow Against State’s Arbitrary Beer Label Ban
  83. Illinois Attorney General's Office Announces Intention to Dismiss False Claims Act Against Liquor Retailers
  84. Commercial Speech And Alcoholic Beverages - Part III
  85. Commercial Speech And Alcoholic Beverages - Part II
  86. Craft Beverages: Social Media Marketing the Effective and Compliant Way
  87. Commercial Speech And Alcoholic Beverages - Part I
  88. A LAYPERSON LOOKS AT ARSENIC IN WINE
  89. The Biggest Retailer in the World vs. the TABC
  90. Rebecca Stamey-White presents Emerging Issues in Wine Law
  91. Top Beverage Alcohol Law Firm Adds and Elevates Partners
  92. Illinois Qui Tam Lawsuits—Private Enforcement Of a State Claim: A Bonanza For A Plaintiff’s Lawyer And A Rip-Off Of Retailers
  93. BOOZE RULES OF SOCIAL MEDIA: The Retailer Right to Pay Exception
  94. LIONS AND TIGERS AND TWEETS, OH MY!
  95. AB 2004: Brewer's Incremental Parity with Wine Makers
  96. Expanding, Proud Of It, and Wanting to Tell the World
  97. DC Weighs in Strongly on Third Party Marketer Delivery Services
  98. “Visual Links” between Beer, Wine and Spirits Labels and Retailers Ruled Unlawful in California — the tied house laws run amok
  99. Hard Cider Legislative Update
  100. New Marketing Model for New York – Lot 18 and the NYSLA